Just sitting back in a moment of extreme cynicism this morning, after looking at the futures which are hinting to S&P 500 this week may close out around 2,075, plus or minus 20, I think we need to have us a discussion about “churn.”
Now, everyone knows what churning is in the dairy sense. You take heavy cream (like whipping cream from the store) beat the snot out of it. And at first you’ll get whipping cream.
But if you keep going, you will also get butter. Toss in some food coloring and salt and…
In the financial world, churning is a little different. A management firm gets a big pile of money to invest, and then then invest long or short in this, or that, and the market does its thing.
Except people don’t realize how easy it is to wrap investment policy people around their fingers, especially when done in a mahogany-line foxhole and immediately followed by a big dinner out or a delicious catered lunch.
When (eventually) the client wakes up to realize that they aren’t making what buying a shoebox full of bonds 5-years ago would have made, they then play something akin to client musical chairs.
The people who make out are the brokerage firms which front-run everyone, but because the SEC is too crooked to call computerized skinning of the client the same (net) as a human broker trading ahead of a client as criminal, everything goes along fine.
Churning is when the client funds go in and out, long or short, when there’s really no need to. Again, the object is to make commissions for all the money people and for the clients, too bad.
So let’s say the S&P closes around 2,075 today (plus or minus 20).
Last week, we closed at 2,077 and change.
On July 24th, we closed at 2,079.65.
A little further? How about April 17: 2,081.16
Well, then, how about December 5th of last year? 2,075.37.
Now the shocker. September 1st, 2000 the S&P 500 was at 1,520.77.
“Hold ‘er right there, Ure: 1,520.77 is less than the 2,075 you’ve gone off on.”
Well, no. Because if you believe that my financially ignorant friend, you’ve been sucked into the fairytale that Wall Street, the Fed, Congress, and the White House all want you to believe.
Because when you use the authoritative Minneapolis Fed inflation calculator (here, try it sometime).
So there you have it. (This is the kind of stuff I tell Peoplenomics.com subscribers about all the time, too…)
America – land of the brave, home of the free, which has listed to all the free-trade bullshit and torn down our borders has – on an inflation adjusted basis – made a slight negative return on on the S&P over the past OMG FIFTEEN FREAKING YEARS.
Sure, there will be those who claim that “Ure’s wrong. He doesn’t include dividends.”
Oh?
I’ll include dividends if you include bankruptcies. And if you include the one other reality the crooks in Washington and Wall Street conceal (CHURN: Commissions times turnovers times fees), I think you’ll understand what and how it is that America is now at an economic break-point.
When people are working harder, longer, and not getting anything additional in return, it becomes what the great sociologist Joseph Tainter describes as the “marginal rate of return on additional effort falls below zero.” Historically, he notes, that’s when countries break-up.
So between now and elections, expect some “hugely useful crisis.” Because without it, a revolution at the polls is likely and a few like Donald Trump are sensing the shift in the herd and are willing to give ‘em what they haven’t had for at least 15-years.
Socioeconomic honesty.
And if goes back 55-years if you want to talk poverty rates and 65-years if you want to talk about working households on one job-holder in a family.
The Magician’s Spell
Can be seen in Producer Prices just out:
The Producer Price Index for final demand advanced 0.2 percent in July, seasonally adjusted, the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics reported today.
Read More