I’m sick of them…so please cease and desist sending me any more emails that liken the current situation in Ukraine to the 1914 period in Kaiser Germany. It’s the wrong analogy and it’s one of those neocon mind-trips attempting to reframe how you view history.
And it’s just plain wrong.
The more correct analogy in history is the pre WW II Anschluss and how that rolled out. Let me run through Wikipedia snips (for the high level view) and maybe you’ll follow what’s going to come next.
We start with Lebensraum (living room or elbow space).
Lebensraum
listen (help·info) (German for “habitat” or literally “living space“) was an important component of Nazi ideology in Germany. The Nazis supported territorial expansionism to gain Lebensraum as being a law of nature for all healthy and vigorous peoples of superior races to displace people of inferior races; especially if the people of a superior race were facing overpopulation in their given territories.[1] The German Nazi Party claimed that Germany inevitably needed to territorially expand because it was facing an overpopulation crisis within its Treaty of Versailles-designed boundaries that Adolf Hitler described: “We are overpopulated and cannot feed ourselves from our own resources”.[1] Thus expansion was justified as an inevitable necessity for Germany to pursue in order to end the country’s overpopulation within existing confined territory, and provide resources necessary to its people’s well-being.[1] The idea of a Germanic people without sufficient space dates back to long before Adolf Hitler brought it to prominence.
Point: What organization in modern-day Europe is in a massive expansionist mode and has declared a territorial (trade to begin with) imperative spanning from Lisbon to Vladivostok?
Answer: Why, the EU, of course.
Counterpoint: And months later, Russia responds.
Next, we move on to the German election and referendum, 1938:
Parliamentary elections were held in Germany (including recently annexed Austria) on 10 April 1938.[1] They were the final elections to the Reichstag during Nazi rule and took the form of a single-question referendum asking whether voters approved of a single list of Nazis and pro-Nazi “guest” candidates for the 813-member Reichstag as well as the recent annexation of Austria (the Anschluss). Turnout in the election was officially 99.5% with 98.9% voting “yes”.[1] In Austria official figures claimed 99.73% voted in favour with a turnout of 99.71%.
And while Crimea voted to side with Russia in this weekend’s elections, it’s a virtual certainty that a similarly polarized outcome will be assured when Ukraine votes in presidential elections.