If this adds a useful perspective
Click here to send this page to a friend

ShopTalk Sunday: Shop Balance

There comes a point, after enough years of owning tools, when a man begins to suspect the tools may have been studying him right back.

What began as a practical little collection — a drill here, a saw there, a soldering iron because one must have standards — slowly turns into a private economy. Every drawer, rack, shelf, cord reel, clamp, jig, printer, torch, and “I’ll use that someday” treasure becomes part of a larger asset-allocation problem. Not the Wall Street kind, where a fellow in loafers waves at pie charts and calls it wisdom, but the real kind: how much time, money, attention, floor space, patience, electricity, and remaining life-force are you willing to assign to making, fixing, improving, or merely owning things?

That is the quiet problem waiting in every shop. You might walk in thinking you are just going to sharpen a blade, fix a hinge, or find the crimpers you swear were on the bench yesterday. But under that errand sits a deeper question: what is this shop for today? Almost everything a person does in a shop falls into one of four buckets. You can innovate, operate, replicate, or maintain. Each has its place. Each can save your bacon. Each can also become a jealous little tyrant if allowed to overrun the others.

The First Bucket: Innovation

Innovation is the glamorous one, though the word has been abused by the same people who brought us “disruption,” “platform,” and software updates that remove useful buttons.

In a real shop, innovation is not a TED Talk. It is the recognition that something is bothering you and that the present arrangement is dumber than it needs to be. Sometimes a problem becomes apparent only after watching your spouse.  Where did that go, and why?

Our redneck wine-and-veggie cooler is a fair example. In East Texas summer, the air conditioner is already dragging heat out of the house and dumping a ribbon of cool air through the floor register. A man with sense eventually asks: why not make that cold air do a little side work before it joins the general population?  Cooling beer (or that jug for Burgundy) is a holy mission from God.

The result was not an appliance that would get applause from a design magazine. It was a box over a cold summer A/C duct. That was the concept. Wine, vegetables, and other things that dislike July could sit in a modest, useful, no-drama cooling space without buying yet another humming contraption, finding a place for it, and feeding it power. It was not elegant in the showroom sense, but it solved the problem in the ranch sense, which is often the higher standard. The ranch does not care whether an answer flatters the catalog. It cares whether the lettuce wilts or the potatoes sprout.  The beer and wine never last too long.

That, reduced to shop grammar, is innovation. See the problem. Test-fit the possible answers. Select the one best suited to the real purpose, not the one best suited to bragging. Then make the build-or-buy decision. That last step is where many shop people go astray. Some build what they should buy because building feels virtuous. Others buy what they should build because buying feels efficient. Both can be wrong. The trick is not to worship either path. The trick is to ask what gives the best answer for the time, cost, reliability, repairability, and satisfaction involved.

Bucket 2: Operate Some Tools

If the answer is “build,” the rest of civilization comes down to a surprisingly short sequence: design, measure, cut, join, and finish. That is furniture. That is a cabinet. That is a chicken-coop door. That is an antenna mount. That is a bracket for a thing that was clearly designed by a committee which never had to install one. Even software, once translated into shop terms, follows the same pattern. Design the logic, measure the requirements, cut away useless complexity, join the pieces, and finish by debugging the parts where reality refused to salute the plan.  (We will skip debugging and compiling lest you’re offended by the attending language.)

The operating side is less romantic but more profitable. Operation is where the tools actually earn their keep. A shop full of tools that never makes, repairs, improves, or rescues anything is not a shop; it is a museum of postponed intentions with better lighting. Operating is the part where projects move from the skull to the bench and then out into the world. A thing gets fixed. A part gets made. A design becomes physical. A leak stops leaking. A gate closes square. A radio gets back on the air. The operator, at least for one blessed moment, feels he has not merely accumulated implements but has actually increased his command over matter.

Bucket 3: Replication (tooling disease)

Then comes replication, and this is where virtue starts wearing a false mustache. Replication is how a man becomes what polite society might call “well-equipped” and what a more honest inventory might call a tool slut. It starts innocently enough. One soldering iron is fine until it isn’t. A tiny battery soldering iron has its place for field work and small emergencies. A hot-air rework station is needed for surface-mount boards and modern electronics that seem to have been assembled by elves with microscopes. A digital adjustable ESD-safe soldering station belongs on the serious bench. Then a 20-volt battery-powered soldering station becomes sensible for outdoor antenna work, where the nearest outlet is always on the wrong side of weather, mud, and common sense.

The same scaling applies to heat generally. First comes the pocket propane torch. Then something hotter. Then the day arrives when oxy-acetylene stops looking like overkill and starts looking like adulthood. Each tool occupies a different heat envelope, portability range, control level, and damage radius. To outsiders it looks like duplication. To the shop operator it is taxonomy. You are not buying the same tool twice. You are buying different answers to related problems.

Replication is why the “best battery tool” for the job is a favorite shop viewpoint.

This explains, at least to my satisfaction, why two CR-10 V2 printers made sense.  G2 is skeptical.  “Why two of everything?”  Well, because son, you only have so much time so a backup for everything – a carryover from offshore sailing.  “OK, dad, but do you really need a 13″ planer AND a Japanese 8″ planer with a 210 volt power converter?” Um, listen kid. I don’t second guess your choice of women, you don’t question my tool choices, OK?

Likewise: A civilian may believe one 3D printer is enough. That belief lasts until one machine is down, one is set up with the wrong filament, one has the wrong nozzle, or one long print is blocking the next urgent idea. I’ve got (at best) maybe 6,000 days left. And if it’s only one or two, I want this (thing) printed.

The same logic begins creeping toward CNC machines. Why two 3020 CNC routers? Because setup time is real time, redundancy is real insurance, and parallel capacity turns “I should make that someday” into “I made two while lunch was warming.” Shops obey different math than accounting departments. Accounting departments worship utilization. Shops worship readiness.

Bucket 4: Maintenance  (How to keep it up?)

And no, not the sort of ‘maintenance’ sold late at night involving Swedish flower pollen, zinc supplements, and smiling retirees in golf shirts. Maintenance is the old mule that actually pulls the wagon while innovation gets invited to the banquet. Every useful system eventually starts asking to be fed. Houses require maintenance. Shops require maintenance. Vehicles require maintenance. Computers require updates, backups, cables, passwords, patches, drivers, and occasional exorcism. Relationships require maintenance, too, though they are less tolerant of being stored under a tarp until spring.

This is where a man must be honest with himself. At some level of complexity, the system begins to threaten the practitioner. A large shop is not just a productive asset; it is a living mouth. It wants lubrication, cleaning, calibration, storage, power, parts, benches cleared, batteries charged, blades sharpened, filters changed, software updated, and little piles sorted before they breed. The operator who once bought tools to save time may discover he now spends his time maintaining the time-saving tools.

The same pattern shows up everywhere. A house can become so complicated that living in it turns into facility management. A website can become so layered with plug-ins, forms, backups, analytics, security, caching, and little flashing warnings that writing becomes the thing done after the machinery has been appeased. Go ahead. Ask me where nine hours disappeared this week.

Even a relationship, if neglected or overcomplicated, can become a maintenance burden instead of a shelter. Honestly, I’ve always looked at buying lingerie as a maintenance item along with…um, let’s hold that for another Sunday.

None of this means complexity is bad. It means complexity must be paid for, and it always sends the bill to the calendar.

That brings us back to shop balance. Too much innovation and nothing gets finished. Sometimes, nothing even gets started. But dammit, innovating is fun and cheaper than more tooling.

Too much operation and the operator burns down like a cheap extension cord under a welder load. Too much replication and the shop turns into a hardware store with no cashier. Too much maintenance and the whole enterprise becomes janitorial service for one’s own ambitions. Balance is not a slogan. It is the daily decision about which bucket deserves the next hour.

Here’s How Logic Fails

Logical thinking helps, but only so far. Logic can tell you whether the parts fit, whether the current draw is safe, whether the lumber is straight enough, or whether the build makes theoretical sense.

What logic cannot always tell you is whether the job deserves your remaining Saturday, whether the tool will truly be used, whether the elegant solution is worth three more trips to town, or whether “good enough” is actually the superior engineering answer in work boots.

For those questions, the old business-school metrics still beat most modern cleverness: time, cost, and customer satisfaction. In a home shop, the customer may be you, your wife, your future self, or the poor soul who will have to repair the thing after your genius has cooled. A technically perfect solution that takes forever may be a failure. A cheap solution that works every time may be a triumph. A beautiful jig nobody enjoys using will gather dust with great dignity. A rough-looking fixture that saves ten minutes every week is a quiet little gold mine.

The older I get, the less impressed I am by raw tool count and the more impressed I am by friction reduction. A good shop makes life easier. It shortens the distance between problem and answer. It gives ideas a place to land. It lets a person repair enough of his world to remain dangerous in a civilization trying to rent him everything by the month. A bad shop does the opposite. It consumes time, hides parts, multiplies guilt, and becomes a museum of things that might have happened if only the owner had another Saturday every week.

So the next time you walk into the shop, it may be worth pausing before reaching for the first tool. Ask what business you are really in today. Are you innovating, operating, replicating, or maintaining? Any answer can be right. The trouble begins when you don’t know which one you’re doing, because that is when the shop quietly takes command.

God forbid the shop starts running the man instead of the other way around. Though sometimes I wonder whether that is half the meaning behind Purgatory or the Bardo: finally being handed all the unfinished projects from life and told, “Well…you said you’d get to them eventually. That’s now…”

Sunday’s “Slower Mower Maunder Ponder”

Just for drill, press this into Ure planer thinking and what did you saw? First they wanted our guns, next it’s our brains, and most folks just wanna be lathed alone.

First there was the Dear John, then the Deere itself showed up. Skil’ed or otherwise, I’m still a Craftsman at heart. Lost faith in Milwaukee, where fools overran tools. Vevor la revolution!

One Nation, under Claude, with Liberty and emu for all.  (And where was Troy-Bilt?)

Write when you’re done. I seem to be.

George@Ure.net

35 thoughts on “ShopTalk Sunday: Shop Balance”

Comments are reviewed by a human because the web is crawling with spammers. Submissions after 4 PM Central usually appear the following morning. After you click Post Comment, you’ll jump back to the top of this article, but your comment is queued up here. We’ve got a robust community and your participation is invited. Some commenters are brilliant. Read a few and judge for yourself. Imagine. You could be one.

  1. Hilarious finish, G!
    As Diane once told Sam Malone on “Cheers”, “You have a way with word.”

  2. Is this a confession – ?

    “YA see I could have bought a Bitcoin TOOL for a couple hundred dollars, or another power Tool, cause 2 ____ers are not enough for one craftsmen.” – G-Pops

    Gonna need my hip waders for all this bullscheisse.

    Out of control you be, why had you not spent all that $$$ on tools and what not, and instead invested the $$$, by golly you could be sailing with Salty Stiks down the IO some wheres around Fromunda Land.
    Hell you could even be in general location of the biggest BEAR in all Aussie land – Lenora Goombaroo. He is a little VIXed right now, but generally a pretty decent kinda guy…in spite of his luv for all things Crypto, including myself.

    * There can be NO Absolution, as there is NO such thing as Sin..as defined by the Mackerel Snappers.

  3. Done is a four letter word rarely used around here. I am done but never the projects. Launched 100′ wood pier and pushed three lifts and the kayak stand off the yard (ahem, for the next time our lawn service has a chance between rain storms). This sets in motion a 3 week project to get done(er). Then it’s summer and Mom’s Rule kicks in : thou shall only do fun work from July 4th to Labor Day. Have fun, smell the roses.

    Speaking of Mom : Happy Mother’s Day all round.
    Moms are the best.
    Egor

  4. My problem is I have a hard time NOT taking on another project.
    Before retirement, I would just write a check, grumble about it a bit and wait for the “It’s done” call. Now it’s “I’m not paying that amount to do (something) I THINK I can do”. Hence, the daughters car transmission disemboweled across one bench, two tables and a pail of parts…

  5. Aging, and diminishing capabilities forced me to start evaluating my tool collection and hobbies about ten years ago. Over that period, I’ve sold some items, given my son most of my power tools, and my grandson most of my hand tools. Today, I have one small toolbox with a few essentials, and a single battery-powered drill. I still do a few small honey-do projects, but most others I rely on my son to take care of. My most-used tools are my mini desk PC with a big monitor and my kindle. I’ve had to learn to do projects in bits, taking time to ‘blow’ between bits. I still get in 2 or 3 hours of writing each day, but I’ve stopped imposing a publishing deadline. If I don’t finish my current work this time around, maybe I’ll finish it in the next realm.

    • see I debated selling my tools . I’m blind in one eye and deminished sight in the other..still can read and do audio books..audible and the LOC was sending me like ten a month..
      but the wife and I talked..what we would get at an auction wouldn’t even come close and I said I would have more enjoyment from watching the kids build something..I try not to use power tools I have no depth of field..

  6. What is Trump going to do now ?
    Iran has sent their peace proposal – via Pakistan – to the White House.

    They will keep control of the Straits [ forever ] – allowing only Iranian friendly ships to pass.., they will not discuss anything nuclear., the U.S. must agree to all of their demands and withdraws the Navy., and remove the blockade.., the Straits will remain closed until the U.S. agrees to all of their demands for peace. Nuclear discussions are completely off the table. Ohh.., and Israel must stop their terrorist attacks in Lebanon.
    – On.., and on…,
    – To me, every point makes this a non-starter.

    Trump is in China at the moment – which is probably why Iran waited so long to reply.

    They have firmly kicked the ball back into the U.S. court and are now awaiting Trump’s response. It’s a proposal for peace – he must respond.

    We will now see exactly what kind of leader Trump really is.

    “It doesn’t matter if you believe in their religion., how you deal with their belief is what matters.”

    Trump has back-pedaled and capitulated so much these past couple of weeks that Iran now firmly believes it has the upper-hand. It doesn’t matter if they do, or don’t.., it’s what “they” believe that matters…., and what Trump decides., right now., could feasibly change the course of history – for us and for the Middle East.

    .., and – does Iran actually have the Chinese hypersonic missile known as the “Carrier Killer” – ?? The loss of one U.S. ship will ignite an all-out war. [ IMO ]

    …, damn !

    “Stay Frosty !”

    • When Trump first met Xi – he told him he just fired a gazillion missiles as a warning. Maybe when Trump meets Xi in China Xi will bend over and tell Trump he just destroyed the carrier groups in the gulf……

    • nah mate . its called sunburn . russia figured in the 80s they couldnt keep up with the american printing presses and their war budget . they had limited finances to develop smarter tactical weapons . wella ! sunburn

    • Trump will do nothing.

      You (and everyone else) below Norman Schwarzkopf in rank learned how to fight from Robert McNamara, which means you learned how to win battles, but not wars.

      Trump is the first non-politician to be CiC since when? He may not understand the more esoteric vagaries of Napoleon’s tactics, but he understands how to be a closer. His belief is nukes should never be used under any circumstance and his “red line” is Iran’s stash. Unless they surrender it — ALL of it, and abandon their nuclear program, any “peace proposal” is a non-starter…

  7. Back in the day… when i was college student.. i had a four year job at a Mobil Chemical factory.. basically i worked with the maintenance – mechanical and electrical guys as helper in whatever they needed.

    Years later.. it is not just the shop that is important.. it is workers. I learned enough about management from the frowns of the maintenance guys.. that i was in management for about 34 years.. which this experience really helped.

    A word about Mobil… the plant manager came up to me at the end of the first summer.. and he said.. well when you going back to school? I said.. well in two weeks.. but i could still work a day or two a week. He said.. let think about it. I told him i would do whatever he wanted.. He came back to me and said i have some rest rooms that need cleaning on saturday or sunday. what do you think? i said “a deal.”

    A fine outfit.

  8. “Write when you’re done. I seem to be.”

    You have exceeded your forgiveness quota. You are hereby sentenced to Pun Purgatory until you finish ALL your projects! Death will be an unacceptable excuse. There is always the next life to continue your sentence.

  9. saw this statue thing of trump . pretty stupid and tacky if you ask me . but i thought his pastor some other freak guy from the carolinas who blessed the thing was up on sexual charges a while ago . or even worse young very young victims . anyone remember that ? anything around da capo boss king of new America is might i say cloudy

    • Is Trump a modern day Nero?

      The Colossus of Nero (Colossus Neronis) was a 30-metre (98 ft) bronze statue that the Emperor Nero (37–68 AD) created in the vestibule of his Domus Aurea, the imperial villa complex which spanned a large area from the north side of the Palatine Hill, across the Velian ridge to the Esquiline Hill in Rome. It was modified by Nero’s successors into a statue of the sun god Sol. The statue was eventually moved to a spot outside the Flavian Amphitheatre, which (according to one of the more popular theories) became known, by its proximity to the Colossus, as the Colosseum.

      https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Colossus_of_Nero

  10. i wouldnt put up statues of myself before i die . i still remember when the folks in iraq pulled over the one of saddam in baghdad . unforgetable . tied ropes to it and pulled it down

    • As the resident “systems and logician” — besides 3P, of course — the issue I see Trump addressing is this: If he doesn’t put up the selfoliths while he’s alive, will anyone be inclined to do so when he’s gone?

      Maybe not.

      Check the M.E. and get back to me this fall.

      • now thats funny !!!! you do have a great way with words in the fun years as the great mel brooks calls them !!!

    • If you put up statues of yourself after you die, let me know where and I’ll come watch…

  11. if claude mythos rang me in a park having lunch in san fran, id say yeah let it go , git it on . i wouldnt command it to stand down and get back in its encrypted cell . it hasnt been a level playing field for bears since king donny said he was going to weaponise AI

  12. Trump does not trust history to portray him in image or otherwise. In fact, he trusts no one but himself. This is not unique to The Donald. Many leaders throughout human history have attempted to write their own legacy. I’ll leave it to the psychologists to ascertain why Trump is the way he is. But Trump is very much a modern day Nebuchadnezzar. He can’t help it. It doesn’t mean that he is evil or bad, just that he is self-glorifying/vain, has to be right, and is more than willing to throw his weight around to make his point. History may not write kindly of him, but it will certainly write about him.

    • “I’ll leave it to the psychologists to ascertain why Trump is the way he is.”

      I ‘splained this about 11 years ago, Lucy:

      Trump is a construction worker, from Queens, with money. He spent the first 50+ years of his life trying unsuccessfully to gain acceptance in the “Manhattan elite” NYC social circles. His personality is what he developed as a defense mechanism when he figured out he could dominate the gossip pages, but he’d never get good copy on the society pages. He likely won’t for some time. Lincoln was a hated pariah for about 60 years after his passing, before his popularity matched his unpopularity. Trump will probably be the same, and I’m sure that doesn’t play well with his ego.

      However, it’s his money…

  13. Happy mothers day to all the ladies out there…
    we had our yearly shrimp boil ..luckily I didn’t get in trouble over not having the sprouts ready for the salads.. mung beans, amaranth and radishes… but it went ok..

  15. Spencer Pratt sits down with CBS for a full hour..

    CBS fact-checks Karen Bass on camera..

    CBS “gets the call”..

    CBS cuts the interview to 5 minutes..

    Pratt posts about it publicly.. calls it a hit piece..

    the internet loses its mind.. demands the real version..

    CBS quietly drops a 30-minute extended cut..

    and here’s the part nobody’s connecting..

    the only reason any of this happened is because Pratt went public.. if he stayed quiet.. you never see 30 seconds of that interview.. let alone 30 minutes..

    a sitting mayor allegedly called a major network after getting fact-checked.. and the network folded.. until the public got loud enough that folding the other way was the safer move..

    that’s not journalism.. that’s damage control with a rewind button..

    the system worked for someone today.. just not for you.

    https://x.com/USronaldcarter/status/2053438879064105129?s=20

  16. ?? ????? ??, ????, ??? ?????????? ??????????? ?????? ?? ????, ??? ???????? ??? ???????? ?????? ??? ??? ??????? ???? ????? ??????????’? ??-??????-??? ??????:
    — 9.9% income tax on household earnings above $1 million
    — 1% annual wealth tax on stocks, bonds, mutual funds, and ETFs over $100 million
    — Capital gains tax raised from 7% to 9.9% on gains above $1 million, retroactive to January 1, 2025

    What happened next was immediate and measurable:
    — 53 homes over $2 million hit the market in a single day after the bill cleared
    — Statewide luxury listings jumped roughly 65% overnight
    — King County listings over $5 million are now up 40% year-over-year
    — Total Washington home listings up 64%
    — Bellevue is full of ‘lock-and-leave’ condos as residents establish out-of-state primary residency under the 183-day rule

    https://x.com/MichaelARothman/status/2053691251669745985?s=20

    • (“53 homes over $2 million hit the market in a single day after the bill cleared”)

      one of the people I seen.. lived in the neighborhood of wealthy home owners.. they would sell… then a month or two later they were bac up for sale.. the wife of the gentleman I visited was frantic ..because of his injury in the army he couldn’t work..the money they had wouldn’t even make taxes on it..the jobs that were out there don’t pay enough even for apartments..she didnt have a clue it was like that for the other people..then daycare she was frantically trying to understand the reality of the real world outside the bubble… the shock of reality had her all upset and in tears.. they were living on….PLASTIC…..

    • Here’s the first part of this (above) post — cleaned of unprintable characters:

      Today’s Bellevue/Eastside Zillow looks like the biggest wave of $5 million-plus luxury listings in Seattle-area history — and it is happening exactly when economists predicted Washington’s new millionaire taxes would trigger it.

      On March 12, 2026, the Washington legislature passed SB 6346 and Governor Bob Ferguson signed the tax package that ended Washington’s no-income-tax status.

      • ‘Problem is, the Democrats have never been this party. They are simply more glib, and better at bullshit than the Republicans…

Comments are closed.